Regulations · CMMC explained

    CMMC for European suppliers to the US Department of Defense.

    Independently tested on the EU AI Act: most accurate single-turn answers, second overall of eight.

    The Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification programme is set out in 32 CFR Part 170 and reaches into contracts through the DFARS clause at 48 CFR 252.204-7021. This page quotes both, and the NIST requirements they point to.

    Who it applies to

    Part 170 applies to “All DoD contract and subcontract awardees that will process, store, or transmit information, in performance of the DoD contract, that meets the standards for FCI or CUI on contractor information systems” (§ 170.3(a)(1)). FCI is federal contract information and CUI is controlled unclassified information; the DFARS clause defines both (48 CFR 252.204-7021(a)). The test is the contract and the information you handle under it, so a European supplier that holds a DoD contract or subcontract and handles FCI or CUI on its own systems falls inside it, subject to the limits in § 170.3(b) and (c).

    The programme covers DoD solicitations and contracts under which a contractor or subcontractor will process, store or transmit FCI or CUI on unclassified contractor information systems, “including those for the acquisition of commercial items (except those exclusively for COTS items) valued at greater than the micro-purchase threshold”, subject to the phase-in and to waivers DoD may grant in advance of the solicitation (§ 170.3(c)). “The requirements of this part do not apply to Federal information systems operated by contractors or subcontractors on behalf of the Government” (§ 170.3(b)). The level is not yours to choose: “DoD Program Managers or requiring activities are responsible for selecting the CMMC Status that will apply for a particular procurement or contract” (§ 170.3(d)), based on whether the information is FCI or CUI.

    The three levels

    Each level adds requirements, and a higher status also satisfies the lower ones for the same assessment scope.

    “The security requirements in CMMC Level 1 are those set forth in 48 CFR 52.204-21(b)(1)(i) through (xv).” The contractor assesses itself and enters the result in the Supplier Performance Risk System (SPRS). “No POA&Ms are permitted for CMMC Level 1.” To stay compliant, “the OSA must conduct a Level 1 self-assessment on an annual basis and submit the results in SPRS, or its successor capability” (§ 170.15(a)(1)).

    “The security requirements in CMMC Level 2 are identical to the requirements in NIST SP 800-171 R2” (§ 170.14(c)(3)). Level 2 comes in two forms: a self-assessment, Level 2 (Self), under § 170.16, or a certification assessment, Level 2 (C3PAO), where the OSC “must obtain a Level 2 certification assessment from an authorized or accredited C3PAO” (§ 170.17(a)(1)). Either way the assessment is repeated every three years, and affirmation “is required for all Level 2 self-assessments at the time of each assessment, and annually thereafter” (§ 170.16(a)(2); § 170.17(a)(2) says the same for Level 2 (C3PAO)).

    “The security requirements in CMMC Level 3 are selected from NIST SP 800-172 Feb2021”, with DoD-assigned parameters, and Table 1 to § 170.14(c)(4) lists them (§ 170.14(c)(4)). One example from that table is IR.L3-3.6.1e: “Establish and maintain a security operations center capability that operates 24/7, with allowance for remote/on-call staff.”

    “A CMMC Status of Final Level 2 (C3PAO) for information systems within the Level 3 CMMC Assessment Scope is a prerequisite to undergo a Level 3 certification assessment.” The assessment is performed by DCMA DIBCAC, and “the Level 3 certification assessment must be performed every three years for all information systems within the Level 3 CMMC Assessment Scope” (§ 170.18(a)).

    Which NIST revision Level 2 uses

    Level 2 is tied to Revision 2 of NIST SP 800-171, not to Revision 3. The assessment method is fixed too: “Assessment of security requirements is prescribed by NIST SP 800-171A Jun2018 (incorporated by reference, see § 170.2) and NIST SP 800-172A Mar2022” (§ 170.14(d)).

    Each SP 800-171 requirement is assessed through its SP 800-171A objectives. Requirement 3.5.3 reads: “Use multifactor authentication for local and network access to privileged accounts and for network access to non-privileged accounts.” (SP 800-171 Rev 2, 3.5.3). Its first assessment objective is that “privileged accounts are identified.” (SP 800-171A, 3.5.3[a]).

    Self-assessment or third-party assessment

    A self-assessment is scored by the contractor and uploaded to SPRS; the Level 2 upload includes the overall score, for example “105 out of 110” (§ 170.16(a)(1)(i)). A certification assessment is carried out by a C3PAO at Level 2 or by DCMA DIBCAC at Level 3, and the assessor submits the results into the CMMC instantiation of eMASS, which passes them to SPRS (§§ 170.17(a)(1) and 170.18(a)(1)).

    The evidence stays with you: the artifacts “must be retained by the OSA for six (6) years from the CMMC Status Date” (§ 170.16(c)(4)). For a cloud service holding CUI at Level 2, the offering must be FedRAMP Moderate or equivalent, for example where “The CSP product or service offering is FedRAMP Authorized at the FedRAMP Moderate (or higher) baseline in accordance with the FedRAMP Marketplace” (§ 170.16(c)(2)(i)).

    Scores and plans of action

    A Level 2 assessment with open items can still give a Conditional status, but only if “The assessment score divided by the total number of CMMC Level 2 security requirements is greater than or equal to 0.8” and “None of the security requirements included in the POA&M have a point value of greater than 1 as specified in the CMMC Scoring Methodology set forth in § 170.24, except SC.L2-3.13.11 CUI Encryption may be included on a POA&M if encryption is employed but it is not FIPS-validated, which would result in a point value of 3”, and none of the six requirements named in § 170.21(a)(2)(iii), among them CA.L2-3.12.4 System Security Plan, is on the POA&M (§ 170.21(a)(2)). That requirement, 3.13.11, reads “Employ FIPS-validated cryptography when used to protect the confidentiality of CUI.” (SP 800-171 Rev 2, 3.13.11). Level 3 has its own list of seven requirements that may not be on a POA&M (§ 170.21(a)(3)).

    “The closing of a POA&M must be confirmed by a POA&M closeout assessment within 180-days of the Conditional CMMC Status Date. If the POA&M is not successfully closed out within the 180-day timeframe, the Conditional CMMC Status for the information system will expire.” (§ 170.21(b)).

    Flow-down to subcontractors

    “Prime contractors shall comply and shall require subcontractors to comply with and to flow down CMMC requirements, such that compliance will be required throughout the supply chain at all tiers with the applicable CMMC level and assessment type for each subcontract” (§ 170.23(a)). A subcontractor that will process, store or transmit only FCI in performance of the subcontract needs Level 1 (Self). “If a subcontractor will process, store, or transmit CUI in performance of the subcontract, then a CMMC Status of Level 2 (Self) is the minimum requirement for the subcontractor.” Where the prime contract requires Level 2 (C3PAO) or Level 3 (DIBCAC), the subcontractor handling CUI needs at least Level 2 (C3PAO) (§ 170.23(a)(1) to (4)).

    The contract clause makes the prime check before it awards: it must “ensure that the subcontractor has a current CMMC certificate or current CMMC status at the CMMC level that is appropriate for the information that is being flowed down to the subcontractor based on the requirements at 32 CFR 170.23.” (48 CFR 252.204-7021(f)(2)).

    When it applies

    DoD brings the requirements into solicitations and contracts in four phases. Phase 1 “Begins on the effective date of the complementary 48 CFR part 204 CMMC Acquisition final rule.” Phases 2, 3 and 4 each begin one calendar year after the previous one. DoD may require Level 2 (C3PAO) at its discretion from Phase 1 and intends to require it as a condition of award for applicable solicitations and contracts from Phase 2, though in Phase 2 it may delay that to an option period. It may require Level 3 (DIBCAC) at its discretion from Phase 2 and intends to require it as a condition of award for all applicable solicitations and contracts from Phase 3, though in Phase 3 it may delay that to an option period. In Phase 4, “DoD will include CMMC Program requirements in all applicable DoD solicitations and contracts including option periods on contracts awarded prior to the beginning of Phase 4.” (§ 170.3(e)).

    Section 170.3(e) counts the phases from the effective date of the 48 CFR part 204 rule and does not state that date itself, so this page gives no calendar dates.

    Questions we get

    Rev 2. Under 32 CFR 170.14(c)(3), the security requirements in CMMC Level 2 are identical to the requirements in NIST SP 800-171 R2, and 170.14(d) prescribes assessment by NIST SP 800-171A Jun2018.

    Under 32 CFR 170.23(a), CMMC requirements reach subcontractors at all tiers that will process, store or transmit FCI or CUI on contractor information systems in performance of the subcontract. One that will handle only FCI in performance of the subcontract needs Level 1 (Self), and one that will handle CUI in performance of the subcontract needs at least Level 2 (Self). Where the prime contract requires Level 2 (C3PAO) or Level 3 (DIBCAC), a subcontractor that will handle CUI in performance of the subcontract needs at least Level 2 (C3PAO).

    Not at Level 1: 32 CFR 170.21(a)(1) permits no plan of action and milestones (POA&M). At Level 2 and Level 3 a Conditional status is possible when the score divided by the number of requirements is at least 0.8 and the POA&M leaves out the requirements 170.21 lists; at Level 2 no POA&M item may carry more than 1 point, with one stated exception for encryption that is employed but not FIPS-validated. The closing of the POA&M must be confirmed by a POA&M closeout assessment within 180 days of the Conditional CMMC Status Date, or the Conditional status expires.

    Level 1 is a self-assessment every year (32 CFR 170.15). Level 2 is assessed every three years, by self-assessment or by a C3PAO, with an affirmation at each assessment and annually thereafter (170.16 and 170.17). Level 3 is a DIBCAC assessment every three years, and a Level 2 (C3PAO) assessment must also be conducted every three years (170.18).

    This page explains the text of 32 CFR Part 170, 48 CFR 252.204-7021 and NIST SP 800-171. It is legal information, not legal advice.

    Ask CMMC with the source attached

    On the free plan, your own AI client searches law, regulation and standards through Ansvar, one jurisdiction, framework or source per question, and every answer carries its source.

    Ask these to see the quality

    Paste one into your agent once Ansvar is connected, and check the section it cites.

    1. Using Ansvar, under 32 CFR 170.21(a)(2), which conditions must a plan of action and milestones meet for a Conditional Level 2 CMMC status? Quote the paragraph.
    2. Using Ansvar, which CMMC status must a subcontractor that handles CUI hold under 32 CFR 170.23(a)? Quote the paragraphs.
    3. Using Ansvar, what does NIST SP 800-171 Rev 2 requirement 3.5.3 require, and what are its SP 800-171A assessment objectives? Quote them.